|
The Two Economies Are Telling Opposite Stories
This morning at 8:30 the Census Bureau reports how much Americans spent in July, and at 10:00 the University of Michigan publishes how they feel about it. The two numbers rarely get read together, and this week they should be. The S&P 500 crossed 7,800 for the first time on Thursday, a fresh record, while the same households the market is implicitly counting on are telling pollsters they feel worse than at almost any point outside a recession. Confidence sits around 55 on the Michigan index, roughly 11 percent below a year ago.
All week these notes tracked Wall Street’s version of events: record highs, an AI spending boom, cooling inflation headlines. Today is the other side of the ledger, the consumer the whole thing depends on.
A recession-level mood at an all-time-high market. Stripped of context, 55 looks unremarkable. Put back in context, it is startling: readings this low on the Michigan sentiment index have historically appeared in downturns, not alongside stock-market records. Households have spent several years absorbing higher prices, and it shows, with sentiment running about 11 percent below a year ago and near the record low set in the spring. The market is priced as though the consumer is fine. The consumer says otherwise.
Spending is the last leg standing. Here is why today’s retail number matters more than the mood. For all their gloom, Americans have kept spending, and that spending is roughly two-thirds of the economy. It has held even as real incomes weakened and even as July’s jobs report showed the economy shedding positions. Economists expect another modest gain today, around 0.3 percent. As long as that holds, the expansion holds. The worry is what funds it: with incomes squeezed, continued spending leans more on savings and credit, which is a harder thing to sustain than a paycheck.
Why the gap can persist, and why it might not. In fairness, soft sentiment has been a poor predictor lately. People have told surveys they feel terrible and then gone shopping anyway, and confidence has actually risen for two straight months off its spring low. The bull case is clean: mood is noise, spending is signal, and spending is fine. The bear case is that confidence this weak eventually shows up in behavior, especially if the job market keeps softening, and that a market at record highs has left no room for it to. Today’s two readings, spending at 8:30 and mood at 10:00, are a live test of which case is winning.
Where that leaves you. You are not only an investor in this economy; you are the consumer it is measuring. If your portfolio is at record highs, it is priced for the shopper to keep shopping. That may hold, but it is worth knowing the expansion now rests on tired, squeezed households rather than on rising incomes or a strong job market. Watch the control group inside today’s retail report, the part that feeds GDP, more than the headline, and watch whether August sentiment slips again. The roughly 4 percent a six-month Treasury bill pays remains the way to stay patient into the bigger tests: core inflation on August 26 and Jackson Hole on August 28.
The market spent the week celebrating, and the consumer spent it worrying, and both can be true for a while. What today’s numbers measure is how much longer. An expansion carried by unhappy households spending money they increasingly have to borrow can run longer than skeptics expect, yet it is a thinner support than a record-high market implies. Spending at 8:30, mood at 10:00, and then the wait for the Fed’s own read on August 26. This week the market voted. Today the country answers.
|