|
The Forecast Factory and What It Actually Tells You
Friday afternoon, UBS raised its year-end S&P 500 target to 7,900 and bumped its EPS estimate to $335. Morgan Stanley sits at 8,000 with a $339 EPS forecast. Oppenheimer holds the high at 8,100. Deutsche Bank says 8,000. The range across 20 major firms runs from Bank of America at 7,100 to Oppenheimer at 8,100. Every single one predicts gains.
This is not news. The Wall Street consensus has called for a positive year 25 straight times, per Paul Hickey at Bespoke Investment Group. The S&P 500 posted negative annual returns in seven of those years: 2000, 2001, 2002, 2008, 2015, 2018, and 2022. In three of them the index lost more than 20%. Not once in a quarter century did the consensus call for a down year.
The Miss, Not the Direction. The useful number is not whether the consensus is right about direction. It is bullish every year. The useful number is how far it misses. Nationwide Financial analyzed 16 years of year-end targets and found strategists underestimated the S&P 500’s return in 13 of them, missing on the upside by an average of roughly 10 percentage points. Bespoke’s 25-year data set puts the average absolute miss at 14.2 points. The bars in that data line up with the actual return exactly once: 2016. One year out of 25.
The direction of the miss matters. In most years the market outperformed the forecast. When strategists predicted 10%, the index delivered 20%. When they predicted 8%, it delivered 24%. The optimism was not optimistic enough. But when the market turned, the miss went the other direction and it went hard. In 2008 the consensus called for roughly 10% gains. The S&P 500 lost 38%. In 2022 targets ranged from 4,400 to 5,300. The index closed at 3,839.
Why They Cluster. Charles Schwab published a note in January explaining why targets bunch together. Career risk dominates forecast risk. A strategist who calls for a down year and is wrong gets fired. A strategist who calls for modest gains and is wrong blends into the crowd. The incentive is to stay near the median. Ed Yardeni, one of the longest-running bulls on the Street, told AdvisorHub in January that even he finds the lack of dissent concerning. “That’s where my counter instincts come out,” he said. “Things have been going my way for so long that it is kind of worrying that everyone else seems to have become optimistic.”
What the Targets Hide. Year-end targets assume continuity. They treat December 31 as the finish line and ignore the path. In 1987 the S&P 500 started at 242 and ended at 247, per Schwab’s analysis. A strategist with a flat year-end target would have been “right.” But the index rose 40% by August, crashed 23% on a single day in October, then recovered into year-end. The target captured none of that. The midterm election pattern is similar. Since 1957 the S&P 500 has averaged a 1% annual return during midterm years with an average intra-year drawdown of 18%, per Motley Fool. 2026 is a midterm year. The current consensus assumes no correction of that magnitude.
Where That Leaves You. The S&P 500 sits at 7,473. The median Wall Street target is 7,700. That implies 3% upside from here to December. A six-month Treasury bill pays above 4%. The consensus is telling you, in its own numbers, that the S&P 500 will likely underperform a money market fund for the rest of the year. That does not mean sell. It means the margin of safety the consensus is offering you is razor-thin. If the track record holds and the actual return misses by its historical average of 14 points, the market will land somewhere none of these targets predicted. In most years that means higher. In the years that matter most it means lower. The targets do not tell you where the market is going. They tell you what the crowd believes. And on Thursday morning, the GDP revision and the PCE deflator will test whether the crowd is right about the two things holding this consensus together: growth and inflation.
Every bank says the market is going up. The track record says they miss by 14 points and never call a down year. The crowd has been wrong seven times in 25 years. The other 18 times they were right about the direction and wrong about the distance. The targets do not tell you where the market will be in December. They tell you where the consensus stands today. And when the consensus is this tight, the surprise is never in the middle.
|