|
The Headline Will Say Inflation Fell. The Core Will Say It Didn’t.
Tomorrow’s CPI release is going to create a contradictory narrative. The headline number will likely show the consumer price index falling month over month for the first time since late 2024, driven by a 9.2% collapse in gasoline prices during June. That drop was real. Brent crude fell from above $100 in early June to $67 by the end of the month after the mid-June ceasefire reopened the Strait of Hormuz. Pump prices followed. The headline year-over-year rate is expected to fall from 4.2% to 3.9%, the first reading below 4% since March. Cable news will call it progress. Social media will call it a turning point. The Fed will look at a different number.
Core CPI, which strips food and energy, is expected to rise 0.3% month over month and hold at 2.9% year over year. That 2.9% rate is exactly where it was in July 2025. Twelve months of no progress. Shelter, which makes up a third of the index, is forecast to rise 0.27%. Motor vehicle insurance, which fell 1.7% in May in what analysts call an anomaly, is likely to rebound. And the World Cup, being hosted across North American cities in June and July, is expected to push up hotel and restaurant prices temporarily. The core number is the one the Fed used to justify its hawkish tilt at the June meeting, when it raised its median PCE inflation forecast to 3.6% from 2.7%, the largest single-meeting upward revision in recent memory. If core prints at 0.3% or higher, that revision holds.
Why the headline number is already outdated. The gasoline decline that will drive the soft headline print happened during the June ceasefire. That ceasefire is now over. Trump declared it finished on Wednesday. The U.S. launched strikes on 90 Iranian targets. Brent crude, which fell to $67 during the period the CPI data covers, is back above $77 as of Friday. Every dollar of the disinflation that will show up in the June headline has already been reversed in real time. The July CPI report, due in August, will reflect $77 oil, not $67 oil. The June print is a photograph of a world that no longer exists.
How to read the bank numbers. Five banks report before the open. On July 4, this newsletter walked through the four lines that matter most in a bank earnings report: loan-loss provisions, credit card charge-off rates, net interest income, and forward guidance. Here is what to watch for Monday specifically. JPMorgan guided a full-year card charge-off rate of 3.4%. If that number rises in Q2, the consumer is deteriorating faster than the bank expected. Bank of America is expected to earn $1.12 per share on $30.7 billion in revenue, with earnings growth of 25%. If loan demand is accelerating, the economy is still borrowing and investing. If provisions are rising, the economy is still borrowing but struggling to pay it back. The distinction matters. Healthy lending growth with stable provisions is a soft landing. Lending growth with rising provisions is the early phase of a credit cycle. PepsiCo already told us the consumer is pulling back. The banks will tell us whether the pullback has reached the balance sheet.
The four scenarios. Monday’s data collision produces four possible outcomes, each with a different market reaction. First: soft headline CPI plus stable bank provisions. This is the best case. The market rallies, rate hike odds fall, and the soft-landing narrative strengthens. Second: soft headline CPI plus rising provisions. This is the mixed case. Inflation looks better on the surface, but banks see consumer stress. The S&P may rally on the CPI but give back gains as the earnings calls unfold. Third: hot core CPI plus stable provisions. This is the hawkish case. The Fed’s focus on core inflation is validated, September hike odds rise, and the Dow gives back more of its recent gains. Fourth: hot core CPI plus rising provisions. This is the worst case. Inflation is sticky and the consumer is cracking. The market reprices both the rate path and the earnings outlook simultaneously.
The options market is pricing 4.4% to 6.0% one-day moves in the bank stocks. That is roughly double the average earnings-day move for the sector, reflecting the CPI overlap. The S&P 500 enters Monday at 7,575, after four consecutive weekly gains. Consumer one-year inflation expectations sit at 3.7%, the highest since September 2023. Three-year expectations are at 3.3%, the highest since June 2022. The market is positioned for relief. If it gets it, the rally extends. If it does not, the repricing will be fast.
Tomorrow morning will generate the most contradictory set of headlines of the quarter. Inflation fell, but only because of a ceasefire that is already over. Core inflation held, because the parts of the economy that don’t run on gasoline are still getting more expensive. And five banks will tell you whether the consumer who stopped buying Pepsi has also stopped paying the credit card bill. Watch the core number, not the headline. Watch the provisions, not the revenue. And remember that the June CPI reflects $67 oil in a world where oil is now $77. The photograph is sharp. The subject has already moved.
|
